Are Hybrids Really That Green? Jay Leno Thinks "Not So Much"
Unfortunately these moments where I think I am having a "dialog" are sometimes too challenging to hybrid fans and I have, erm, upset them on occasion. For example, practically every person who is referred in this article about hybrids retaining their value got cross with my questions about if their hybrid investments were actually worth the environmental impact that the manufacturing actually costs.
But I am not the only one, I swear! Jay Leno has done a at least a couple of interviews now about this very subject. Of course Jay, in his entire luckiness, is sitting on a mountain of investments other people call collector cars but the jest of his point is that many of these cars have less environmental impact thank current hybrid technologies because they are fuel efficient and their manufacturing impact has practically expired because they were made 40+ years ago.
There are all sorts of number out there that I am currently trying to sort through (statistics not being my forte) that indicate that based on the typical 3-year trade in mentality that most hybrid owner demographics practice, the production of a hybrid has more of a negative environmental impact than the typical Ford F-350 owner. These numbers are based on some of those magical numbers that constitute a carbon footprint profile and include the total number of BTUs needed to manufacture something. For example, a common hybrid on the market will take the equivalent of 1,000 gallons of gas before it has a low carbon impact. Ford's pickups stay on the road an amazing number of years and pass through many owners without costing the environment any additional manufacturing impact.
John McCain even believes that we need to "leapfrog" current hybrid trends. Can we scramble fast enough to get the prize or, in light of the auto manufacturers now finally realizing that they were lazy and need to do some great R&D now for cars that will likely not be in production until post-2011, should we just wait and hold on to the cars that we have?
Not many of us would consider driving a Model T around but we do have to question whether a new car is always a necessity. Sure, older cars break but in the current economic climate, is a car payment on top of negative environmental consequences always the best idea?
XOO,M
Michelle Naranjo
Labels: collector cars, Hybrids, MotaGreen, Used Cars
Stumble It!




